EventsExecutor misses one-shot-timer and never executes it again.

Abierto

#2,803 abierto el 11/4/2025 3 comentarios 0 reacciones 1 asignado Ver en GitHub

Los mantenedores suelen responder en 1 día

@jmachowinski ya está trabajando en esto.

Desde el 24/4/2025.

Evaluación

Este issue todavía no se ha evaluado.

Descripción

bug

Operating System:

Linux robin-zeal 6.9.3-76060903-generic #202405300957~1732141768~22.04~f2697e1~dev-Ubuntu SMP PREEMPT_DY x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux

ROS version or commit hash:

jazzy

RMW implementation (if applicable):

rmw_zenoh_cpp

RMW Configuration (if applicable):

No response

Client library (if applicable):

rclcpp

'ros2 doctor --report' output

ros2 doc --report

<COPY OUTPUT HERE>

Steps to reproduce issue

Run this code

#include <chrono>
#include <memory>

#include <rclcpp/rclcpp.hpp>

using namespace std::chrono_literals;

class ExecutorBugNode : public rclcpp::Node
{
public:
  ExecutorBugNode()
  : Node("executor_bug_node")
  {
    wall_timer_ = create_wall_timer(
      50ms, std::bind(&ExecutorBugNode::wall_timer_callback, this));
  }

private:
  void
  wall_timer_callback()
  {
    if (counter_ < 100) {
      std::this_thread::sleep_for(40ms);
      counter_++;
    } else {
      RCLCPP_INFO(get_logger(), "Sleep stopped");
    }

    if (!one_shot_timer_) {
      one_shot_timer_ = create_wall_timer(
        0s, std::bind(&ExecutorBugNode::one_shot_timer_callback, this));
    } else {
      RCLCPP_INFO(get_logger(), "One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.");
    }
  }

  void
  one_shot_timer_callback()
  {
    RCLCPP_INFO(get_logger(), "--- One-shot timer callback triggered! ---");
    if (one_shot_timer_) {
      one_shot_timer_->cancel();
      one_shot_timer_.reset();
    }
  }

  size_t counter_ = 0;
  rclcpp::TimerBase::SharedPtr wall_timer_;
  rclcpp::TimerBase::SharedPtr one_shot_timer_;
};


int
main(int argc, char ** argv)
{
  rclcpp::init(argc, argv);
  auto node = std::make_shared<ExecutorBugNode>();
  rclcpp::experimental::executors::EventsExecutor executor;
  executor.add_node(node);
  executor.spin();
  executor.remove_node(node);
  rclcpp::shutdown();
  return 0;
}

Expected behavior

The one-shot timer callback should be called every time, or at least every time after the sleep part ends.

Actual behavior

The one-shot timer callback gets called a few times at the start, then it never gets called again even after the sleep part ends.

Additional information

The sleep is there because the event seems to be missed only when the executor takes a while handling other things. Once the event is missed, it is stuck forever.
On the single-threaded executor the callback gets called every single time, it never skips creation.

[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.146] [executor_bug_node]: --- One-shot timer callback triggered! ---
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.196] [executor_bug_node]: --- One-shot timer callback triggered! ---
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.246] [executor_bug_node]: --- One-shot timer callback triggered! ---
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.346] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.396] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.446] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.496] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.546] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.596] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.646] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.696] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.746] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.796] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.846] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.896] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.946] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:04.995] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.462] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.962] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.146] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.196] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.246] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.295] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.346] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.396] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.445] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.496] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.546] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.596] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.646] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.696] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.746] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.796] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.846] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.896] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.946] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:05.996] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.460] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.961] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.146] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.196] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.245] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.296] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.346] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.395] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.446] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.496] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.545] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.596] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.646] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.696] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.746] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.796] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.846] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.896] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.946] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:06.995] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.460] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.960] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.146] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.196] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.246] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.296] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.346] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.396] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.445] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.496] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.546] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.596] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.646] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.696] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.746] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.796] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.846] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.896] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.946] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:07.996] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.458] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.958] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.145] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.196] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.246] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.295] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.346] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.396] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.445] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.495] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.546] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.596] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.646] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.695] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.745] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.796] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.846] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.896] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.946] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:08.996] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.458] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.959] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.105] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.105] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.155] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.155] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.205] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.205] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.255] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.256] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.305] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.306] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.355] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.355] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.405] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.405] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.455] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.456] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.505] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.505] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.555] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.556] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.605] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.606] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.655] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.656] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.705] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.706] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.755] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.756] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.805] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.806] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.855] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.856] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.906] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.906] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.955] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:09.955] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:10.589] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:10.601] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:10.558] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:10.559] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:10.105] [executor_bug_node]: Sleep stopped
[INFO] [2025-04-11 07:26:10.106] [executor_bug_node]: One-shot timer already exists. Skipping creation.
....

Lenguaje dominante: C++
Estrellas: 805
Forks: 564
Merge medio: 1 d 22 h
PR fusionados (30 d): 21

Preparar el entorno

Leer la guía de contribución

Primeros pasos

Lee el issue completo y luego la guía de contribución del proyecto.
Comenta en el issue que vas a ocuparte — evita que dos personas hagan lo mismo.
Haz un fork del repositorio y trabaja en una rama.
Abre un pull request que haga referencia al número del issue.

Más de ros2/rclcpp

Delete ament_export_include_directories() and ament_export_libraries() calls
Abierto
- ¿Algo no está bien?
good first issue

Dificultad 1/5 Menos de una hora Aptitud para principiantes 90/100

ros2/rclcpp#3285 · Abierto el 23/9/2026

Los mantenedores suelen responder en 1 día
Public API in detail namespace - `rclcpp::node_interfaces::detail::NodeInterfacesSupport`
Abierto
- ¿Algo no está bien?
enhancement

Dificultad 2/5 1-3 horas Aptitud para principiantes 70/100

ros2/rclcpp#3281 · Abierto el 20/9/2026

Los mantenedores suelen responder en 1 día
Cannot publish action feedback in CANCELING state
Abierto
- ¿Algo no está bien?
bug

Dificultad 3/5 1-2 días Aptitud para principiantes 65/100

ros2/rclcpp#3283 · 2 comentarios · Abierto el 22/9/2026

Los mantenedores suelen responder en 1 día
:farmer: benchmark_executor tests consistently timeout on Ubuntu Resolute AMD64
Abierto
- ¿Algo no está bien?
bug

Dificultad 4/5 3-5 días Aptitud para principiantes 48/100

ros2/rclcpp#3273 · 2 comentarios · Abierto el 14/9/2026

Los mantenedores suelen responder en 1 día
Support lifecycle-managed timers in rclcpp_lifecycle::LifecycleNode
Abierto
- ¿Algo no está bien?
enhancement

Dificultad 5/5 Más de una semana Aptitud para principiantes 30/100

ros2/rclcpp#3255 · 7 comentarios · Abierto el 4/9/2026

Los mantenedores suelen responder en 1 día

Todos los issues de ros2/rclcpp

Issues similares

drm: possibleCrtcs is read once per connector, so a Type-C port the driver reroutes to another CRTC never gets one until restart
Abierto
- ¿Algo no está bien?
Dificultad 2/5 1-3 horas Aptitud para principiantes 78/100

hyprwm/aquamarine#426 · Abierto el 27/9/2026

Los mantenedores suelen responder en 1 día
Winget hash mismatch for 5.0.3.0
Abierto
- ¿Algo no está bien?
Dificultad 2/5 1-3 horas Aptitud para principiantes 62/100

amnezia-vpn/amnezia-client#3222 · Abierto el 27/9/2026

Los mantenedores suelen responder en 2 días
[TEST] Flaky: test_eviction_with_search_index[allkeys-random] — tag search returns 0
Abierto
- ¿Algo no está bien?
Dificultad 2/5 1-3 horas Aptitud para principiantes 86/100

valkey-io/valkey-search#1465 · Abierto el 27/9/2026

Los mantenedores suelen responder en 1 día
Simple Engine audio chapter: sources are not actually spatialized
Abierto
- ¿Algo no está bien?
Dificultad 2/5 1-3 horas Aptitud para principiantes 78/100

KhronosGroup/Vulkan-Tutorial#524 · Abierto el 27/9/2026

Los mantenedores suelen responder en 1 día
OnnxRuntimeGenAIChatClient duplicates the last token when JSON-schema guidance completes the generation
Abierto
- ¿Algo no está bien?
Dificultad 2/5 1-3 horas Aptitud para principiantes 88/100

microsoft/onnxruntime-genai#2633 · Abierto el 26/9/2026

Los mantenedores suelen responder en 1 día

Más issues de C++

EventsExecutor misses one-shot-timer and never executes it again.

¿Algo no está bien?

Evaluación

Descripción

Operating System:

ROS version or commit hash:

RMW implementation (if applicable):

RMW Configuration (if applicable):

Client library (if applicable):

'ros2 doctor --report' output

Steps to reproduce issue

Expected behavior

Actual behavior

Additional information

Preparar el entorno

Primeros pasos

Más de ros2/rclcpp

¿Algo no está bien?

¿Algo no está bien?

¿Algo no está bien?

¿Algo no está bien?

¿Algo no está bien?

Issues similares

¿Algo no está bien?

¿Algo no está bien?

¿Algo no está bien?

¿Algo no está bien?

¿Algo no está bien?

Recibe los nuevos issues en tu correo