MapMatching Rigidly Follows Traffic Laws

Bắt đầu với API mapMatching và xem xét issue liên quan #849, sau đó theo dõi cách các tuyến OSRM tùy chỉnh được truyền qua Java SDK. So sánh hành vi tuyến đường được yêu cầu cho first responders với luồng hướng dẫn bằng giọng nói và banner hiện tại. Công việc được xem là hoàn tất khi có một cách rõ ràng, được hỗ trợ để tạo ra các hướng dẫn đó mà không từ chối những tuyến đường vi phạm luật giao thông.

The mapMatching API doesn't work with routes that disobey traffic laws. We are providing routes for first-responders (fire, law-enforment, EMS, etc.) who don't always need to obey traffic laws so this is causing issues.

Here's an example (the image on the left is the recommended route; the image on the right is what is returned from mapMatching, not allowing the illegal left turn):

We are generating routes from our own OSRM server using custom profiles and want to use mapbox-navigation-ios for the navigation frontend. As noted in this tutorial and https://github.com/Project-OSRM/osrm-text-instructions/issues/269#issuecomment-449417857 the recommended approach is to use the mapMatching api to add voice and banner instructions to the custom generated route object (orsm-text-instructions could be used to add the simple text instructions but not the voice and banner instructions).

We don't even need the "matching" part of the mapMatching api... we already have the precise road geometry, we're not snapping fuzzy gps coordinates to a road network. We only need the voice and banner instructions but there doesn't seem to be a way to get just these without using the mapMatching API.

We could write our own package to produce the voice and text instructions based on the route object (returned from orsm) and the simple text instructions (returned from osrm-text-instructions) but it seems needless considering this is something already implemented by Mapbox but not available in any way (open source or api).

We plan to reach out directly to Mapbox support to talk about this but I wanted to post a public issue here so that other's could add to the discussion if they have similar issues or possible solutions.

related to #849