Code review skill produces wildly different results between Claude and Codex

Open
#835 3 comments 0 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub

Maintainers usually reply within 1 day

Nobody has claimed this yet.

Assessment

Difficulty
4/5
Estimated time
1-2 days
Newbie friendliness
47/100
Issue type
Bug
Clarity
Mostly clear
Activity status
Quiet
Tech stack
typescript

Research direction

The report describes inconsistent findings from /ce-code-review in Codex and Claude and mentions a possible connection to issue #799, but names no implementation files or tests. Start by reading the skill implementation and issue #799, then compare how reviewer outputs are collected and synthesized across the two integrations. Done means the same diff produces a consistent, adequately reconciled report, with a regression check covering the reported behavior.

Written by the indexing model from the issue text.

Description

Hi there,

First of all, thank you for creating such a great plugin. I've been using it for some time now and it's been great.

I've primarily been a Claude user, but lately I've been testing Codex and I've noticed a big difference in how the /ce-code-review skill behaves between the two.

When used against the same task/commit diff, Codex tends to return single-digit findings, while Claude usually produces double-digit findings. The difference between the two is pretty significant.

When I asked Codex why there was such a difference between the results, it said:

I did not spawn the full applicable reviewer set for the final diff.
I did not create/read a fresh run artifact and then synthesize from every reviewer output.
I over-applied the “validate and drop weak findings” mindset before showing you the raw-to-final mapping.
Claude Code has a more direct implementation path for this CE skill; in Codex I had to manually emulate it with spawn_agent, and I under-emulated it.

This isn't a one-off, it consistently happens every time I run the skill. Is this a bug or a limitation of Codex? I'm also not sure if it's related to this https://github.com/EveryInc/compound-engineering-plugin/issues/799 ?


Edit: here's some more comments from Codex:

Why results diverged:

Claude artifacts include raw reviewer output, not just final merged findings. Many items are testing_gaps or residual_risks, not primary findings. My final report only surfaced the main actionable findings and summarized coverage too tightly.

A lot of Claude’s raw findings violate the skill’s strict merge schema: severity values like high/medium/low, confidence values like 90/95/80. Under the skill’s Stage 5 validation, those are supposed to be dropped or normalized before final synthesis. I dropped some instead of salvaging/normalizing useful content.

I demoted or omitted several “coverage-only” items that Claude preserved, ....

Reviewer nondeterminism is real here. Different harness, model tiering, and agent implementations produced different issue discovery. But that does not fully excuse it: several Claude findings are valid and I should have caught or at least surfaced them as testing gaps/residual risks.

I also compressed the final report too much after applying the one safe fix. The skill asks for richer Coverage, Deployment Notes, and residual/actionable tables. My final answer was materially thinner than the Claude artifact set.

So the honest answer: I did spawn the required agents, but my synthesis pass was stricter and less complete than it should have been. The biggest actual miss is not agent coverage; it is that I failed to reconcile valid raw signals into the final report.
Dominant language
TypeScript
Stars
25.6k
Forks
2.1k
Avg merge
3h 57m
Merged PRs (30d)
170

Getting set up

This project ships no dev container, Dockerfile or contributing guide, so setting up is up to you: start from its README, and see our first-contribution guide for the general steps.

First steps

  1. Read the whole issue, then the project's contributing guide.
  2. Comment on the issue to say you are picking it up — it saves two people doing the same work.
  3. Fork the repository and make your change on a branch.
  4. Open a pull request that references the issue number.

More from EveryInc/compound-engineering-plugin

All issues in EveryInc/compound-engineering-plugin

Similar issues

More TypeScript issues

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.