jpillora/chisel

Today Microsoft Security Essentials started to flag all chisel versions as a hacking tool

Open

#279 创建于 2021年5月21日

在 GitHub 查看
 (19 评论) (20 反应) (0 负责人)Go (1,587 fork)github user discovery
duplicatehelp wanted

仓库指标

Star
 (16,097 star)
PR 合并指标
 (PR 指标待抓取)

描述

Today Microsoft updated the database for security essentials and Windows Defender. Therefore, all software using chisel on Microsoft will be prevented from running because it is considered a "hack tool". The argument is that "Hacktools can be used to patch or "crack" some software so it will run without a valid license or genuine product key."

I strongly disagree with the fact that Microsoft can just blacklist an open source tcp tunnel software library without blacklisting all such tunnels. If a software misuses an open source library the software doing so should be banned, not the underlying library providing a technical means.

The solution is to whitelist this but this is not very elegant.

This has also been discussed previously here #229 for another anti-virus vendor and is flagged as won't fix. I guess this will end up as won't / can't fix as well? But maybe we should address this with Microsoft?

贡献者指南