Inconsistent scope defaults: rtk discover (project) vs rtk gain (global) · rtk-ai/rtk#1582

(1 commento) (0 reazioni) (0 assegnatari)Rust (2914 fork)batch import

area:clieffort-mediumenhancementhelp wantedpriority:medium

Metriche repository

Star: (48.085 star)
Metriche merge PR: (Merge medio 11g 1h) (45 PR mergiate in 30 g)

Descrizione

Problem

rtk discover and rtk gain have inconsistent scope defaults AND the --all flag means different things on each:

Command	Default scope	`--all` means
`rtk discover`	current project	scan all projects
`rtk gain`	global (all projects)	show all time breakdowns (daily + weekly + monthly)

So --all means "widen scope" on discover but "widen time range" on gain. Running both commands to understand RTK coverage requires opposite flags for scope, and --all is a footgun that does something unexpected on gain.

Expected

Consistent scope defaults — both should default to global (more useful), with --project to narrow
Consistent --all semantics — or avoid reusing --all for unrelated purposes across commands

Suggested fix

rtk discover: default to global, add --project flag to narrow (matching rtk gain)
Rename rtk gain --all to something like --full or --breakdown to avoid the semantic collision

Guida contributor

Direzione di ricerca: Esamina le definizioni degli argomenti CLI per i comandi 'rtk discover' e 'rtk gain'. Individua l'impostazione predefinita dell'ambito e modifica il default di 'discover' in globale. Quindi trova il flag ' all' in 'gain' e rinominalo in ' full' o simile, aggiornando di conseguenza documentazione e test.
Tech stack: rust
Dominio: cli
Tipo issue: Bug
Difficoltà: 2
Tempo stimato: 1-3 ore
Stato attività: Attiva
Chiarezza: Chiara
Prerequisiti: RustGit
Adatta ai principianti: 75