Microsoft/TypeScript

Treating `undefined` parameters as optional

Open

#12.400 aperta il 21 nov 2016

Vedi su GitHub
 (42 commenti) (76 reazioni) (0 assegnatari)TypeScript (6726 fork)batch import
CommittedHelp WantedSuggestion

Metriche repository

Star
 (48.455 star)
Metriche merge PR
 (Merge medio 6g 17h) (9 PR mergiate in 30 g)

Descrizione

tsc: 2.2.0-dev.20161116

Discover this behavior from https://github.com/acdlite/flux-standard-action/pull/45/commits/78a9065914b2ca4848dfba8fc0b47c54e2d0e319

This is the original code:

export interface FSA<Payload, Meta> {
  ...
  payload?: Payload;
  ...
}

However, this does not work well with type guard:

function isSomeAction(action: any): action is FSA<{ message: string }, void> {
  return true;
}

let action = {...};
if (isSomeAction(action)) {
  // `action.payload` may be undefined.
  console.log(action.payload.message);
}

Since generic type can be anything, including undefined, I'm considering to remove the optional designation:

export interface FSA<Payload, Meta> {
  ...
  payload: Payload;
  ...
}

// now type guard works
let action = {...};
if (isSomeAction(action)) {
  console.log(action.payload.message);
}

However, now the creation code fail:

function createSomeAction(): FSA<undefined, undefined> {
  // error: `payload` and `meta` are required
  return { type: 'SOME_ACTION' };
}

The workaround is to depends on infer type:

function createSomeAction() {
  return { type: 'SOME_ACTION' };
}

or specify it:

function createSomeAction(): FSA<undefined, undefined> {
  return { 
    type: 'SOME_ACTION',
    payload: undefined,
    meta: undefined
  };
}

Is there a better solution? 🌷

Guida contributor