gen_ai spans (invoke_agent / execute_tool) omit calling user identity and client IP — add enduser.id / client.address

Open
#577 0 comments 0 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub

Nobody has claimed this yet.

Assessment

Difficulty
5/5
Estimated time
Over a week
Newbie friendliness
35/100
Issue type
Feature
Clarity
Mostly clear
Activity status
Quiet
Tech stack
aws, python

Research direction

Start by tracing the SDK's telemetry entry points around strands.telemetry.tracer and the managed harness spans, then verify whether caller identity and client address are available to this repository or only to the AgentCore service. Compare the POST /invocations, invoke_agent, and execute_tool spans in CloudWatch, and consider the OpenTelemetry enduser and client conventions; done means a supported design or implementation can attribute spans without relying on unjoinable CloudTrail data.

Written by the indexing model from the issue text.

Description

Summary

The GenAI observability spans emitted for an AgentCore-hosted agent
(invoke_agent, execute_tool, chat, POST /invocations) contain no identity
of the caller who invoked the agent and no client IP address
. The invoking IAM
principal / end user and the real client address are absent from every span and from
the correlated GenAI content log records. This makes it impossible to attribute an
agent session (and its tool calls) to who triggered it using CloudWatch
observability alone.

Observed spans — no identity/network attributes

For a full invocation I inspected every span (verified live). None carry any
caller-identity or client-IP attribute:

  • invoke_agent Strands Agents — has gen_ai.*, gen_ai.usage.*, harness.id,
    session.id; no user or client address.
  • execute_tool <tool> — has gen_ai.tool.*, session.id; no user or client address.
  • chat / chat <model> — model attrs only.
  • POST /invocations (LOCAL_ROOT) — has only internal transport values
    (net.peer.ip = 127.0.0.1, http.host = 127.0.0.1:8080,
    http.url = http://cell01.us-east-2.prod.arp.kepler-analytics.aws.dev/invocations);
    the external caller's IP/identity is not present.

So neither the identity nor the true client address of the InvokeAgentRuntime
caller is propagated onto the spans.

Relevant OpenTelemetry semantic conventions (the schema gap)

These spans should be able to carry the caller identity and client address using
existing OTel conventions:

End user identityhttps://opentelemetry.io/docs/specs/semconv/registry/attributes/enduser/

Attribute Type Description
enduser.id string Unique identifier of an end user (username/email/…) — PII
enduser.pseudo.id string Pseudonymous (non-PII) end-user identifier
user.roles string[] (replaces deprecated enduser.role)

Client / networkhttps://opentelemetry.io/docs/specs/semconv/registry/attributes/client/

Attribute Stability Description
client.address Stable Client address behind any intermediaries (the real caller IP)
client.port Stable Client port
user_agent.original Stable Client user agent

None of these are populated on the AgentCore/Strands GenAI spans.

Request

Stamp the invoking caller's identity and client address onto the agent spans
(at minimum the root invoke_agent / POST /invocations span, ideally inherited by
child execute_tool spans), using the OTel conventions above:

  • enduser.id (or enduser.pseudo.id for privacy) — the invoking principal / end
    user (e.g. from the InvokeAgentRuntime caller identity, or from the
    X-Amzn-Bedrock-AgentCore-Runtime-User-Id header when
    InvokeAgentRuntimeForUser is used).
  • client.address (+ client.port, user_agent.original) — the real client that
    called InvokeAgentRuntime, not the internal 127.0.0.1 loopback currently on
    POST /invocations.

Gating these behind an opt-in (they are sensitive/PII) is fine.

Why this can't be worked around today

The caller identity and real client IP do exist in the InvokeAgentRuntime
CloudTrail data event (userIdentity, sourceIPAddress, userAgent) — but that
event has requestParameters: null and shares no join key with the spans
(session.id is not in CloudTrail; requestID/eventID are not in any span). A full
field-value intersection of the two returns only the region. So identity cannot be
attached to a span/session from telemetry alone — it must be captured client-side. Put
another way: the data exists in CloudTrail but is unjoinable to the spans, which is
exactly why stamping enduser.id / client.address onto the spans is needed.

Environment

  • Amazon Bedrock AgentCore managed harness (Strands agent, amazon.nova-lite-v1:0),
    region us-east-2.
  • Spans from strands.telemetry.tracer, telemetry.auto.version = 0.18.0-aws,
    delivered to CloudWatch aws/spans (Transaction Search enabled).
  • Verified: no enduser.*, client.address, or external sourceIPAddress on any
    span; POST /invocations shows only internal loopback transport values.

Steps to reproduce the behavior

Prereqs: an AgentCore-hosted agent (e.g. managed harness running Strands) with at
least one tool, and CloudWatch Transaction Search enabled (spans in aws/spans).

  1. Invoke the agent with a fresh session id, from a client with an identifiable AWS
    principal (assumed-role/SSO) and a routable public IP:

        harnessArn="<HARNESS_ARN>",
        runtimeSessionId=sid,
        messages=[{"role": "user", "content": [{"text":
            "Use the <tool> tool to get info, then summarize it in one sentence."}]}], ) for _ in resp.get("stream", []):
        pass print("session:", sid)
    
    
  2. Pull the spans for that session from CloudWatch Logs group  aws/spans  and dump
    every span's attributes:
    limit=5000, filterPattern=f'"{sid}"') for e in r["events"]:
    m = json.loads(e["message"])
    if m.get("name"):
    print(m["name"], "→", sorted(m.get("attributes", {})))

  3. Inspect the root span  POST /invocations  and the  invoke_agent  /  execute_tool 
    spans for any caller-identity or client-address attribute.

Result: no span contains  enduser.id ,  enduser.pseudo.id ,  client.address ,
 client.port , or  user_agent.original . The only network values are internal
( POST /invocations :  net.peer.ip = 127.0.0.1 ,  http.host = 127.0.0.1:8080 ); the
external caller's IP and identity never appear. (The real caller IP + IAM principal are
present only in the  InvokeAgentRuntime  CloudTrail data event, which shares no join
key with these spans.)

Expected behavior

The invoking caller's identity and real client address should be recorded on the agent
spans using the standard OpenTelemetry conventions, so a session/trace can be attributed
to who triggered it from CloudWatch alone:

•  enduser.id  (or  enduser.pseudo.id  for a non-PII identifier) = the invoking
principal / end user (from the  InvokeAgentRuntime  caller identity, or from
 X-Amzn-Bedrock-AgentCore-Runtime-User-Id  when  InvokeAgentRuntimeForUser  is used).
•  client.address  (+  client.port ,  user_agent.original ) = the real client that
called  InvokeAgentRuntime  — not the internal  127.0.0.1  loopback.

At minimum these should appear on the root  invoke_agent  /  POST /invocations  span and
be inheritable by child  execute_tool  spans. Gating them behind an opt-in (PII) is fine.

Additional context

• This is a service-level gap: the agent runs behind the AgentCore runtime's internal
proxy, so the agent/tracer only sees  127.0.0.1 . Only the managed runtime/service can
inject the true external caller identity/IP — hence filed here rather than against the
Strands SDK.
• Cannot be worked around from telemetry: the caller identity + real IP exist in the
 InvokeAgentRuntime  CloudTrail data event ( userIdentity ,  sourceIPAddress ,
 userAgent ), but that event has  requestParameters: null  and shares no per-invocation
key with the spans — a full field-value intersection of the two returns only the region.
(Companion request: "Add  runtimeSessionId  to the  InvokeAgentRuntime  CloudTrail data
event" — the two together close the attribution gap from either side.)
• OTel references: end-user attrs
https://opentelemetry.io/docs/specs/semconv/registry/attributes/enduser/ ·
client attrs https://opentelemetry.io/docs/specs/semconv/registry/attributes/client/
• Env: managed harness, Strands agent ( amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 ), region us-east-2;
spans from  strands.telemetry.tracer ,  telemetry.auto.version = 0.18.0-aws .

Dominant language
Python
Stars
764
Forks
149
Avg merge
1d 19h
Merged PRs (30d)
7

Contributor guide

Open the contributing guide

First steps

  1. Read the whole issue, then the project's contributing guide.
  2. Comment on the issue to say you are picking it up — it saves two people doing the same work.
  3. Fork the repository and make your change on a branch.
  4. Open a pull request that references the issue number.

More from aws/bedrock-agentcore-sdk-python

All issues in aws/bedrock-agentcore-sdk-python

Similar issues

More Python issues

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.